Galaxy bulges and their black holes: a requirement for the quenching of star formation

One of the central features of the last 8 to 10 billion years of cosmic history has been the emergence of a well-populated red sequence of non-star-forming galaxies. A number of models of galaxy formation and evolution have been devised to attempt to explain this behavior. Most current models require feedback from supermassive black holes (AGN feedback) to quench star formation in galaxies in the centers of their dark matter halos (central galaxies). Such models make the strong prediction that all quenched central galaxies must have a large supermassive black hole (and, by association, a prominent bulge component). I show using data from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey that the observations are consistent with this prediction. Over 99.5% of red sequence galaxies with stellar masses in excess of 10^{10} M_{\sun} have a prominent bulge component (as defined by having a Sersic index n above 1.5). Those very rare red sequence central galaxies with little or no bulge (n<1.5) usually have detectable star formation or AGN activity; the fraction of truly quenched bulgeless central galaxies is <0.1% of the total red sequence population. I conclude that a bulge, and by implication a supermassive black hole, is an absolute requirement for full quenching of star formation in central galaxies. This is in agreement with the most basic prediction of the AGN feedback paradigm.Comment: 6 pages, 4 color figures (figure 1 is of slightly degraded quality). To appear in August 1 edition of the Astrophysical Journa

Do the low PN velocity dispersions around elliptical galaxies imply that these lack dark matter?

While kinematical modelling of the low PN velocity dispersions observed in the outer regions of elliptical galaxies suggest a lack of dark matter around these galaxies, we report on an analysis of a suite of $N$-body simulations (with gas) of major mergers of spiral galaxies embedded in dark matter halos, and find that the outer velocity dispersions are as low as observed for the PNe. The inconsistency between our dynamical modelling and previous kinematical modelling is caused by very radial stellar orbits and projection effects when viewing face-on oblate ellipticals. Our simulations (weakly) suggest the youth of PNe around ellipticals, and we propose that the universality of the PN luminosity function may be explained if the bright PNe in ellipticals are formed after the regular accretion of very low mass gas-rich galaxies.Comment: Contributed talk at meeting, "Planetary Nebulae as astronomical tools", Gdansk, Poland, June-July 2005, ed. R. Szczerba, G. Stasi\'nska, and S. K. G\'orny, AIP Conference Proceedings, Melville, New York, 2005. 4 or 5 pages, 6 figure

Evidence for a Positive Cosmological Constant from Flows of Galaxies and Distant Supernovae

Recent observations of high-redshift supernovae seem to suggest that the global geometry of the Universe may be affected by a `cosmological constant', which acts to accelerate the expansion rate with time. But these data by themselves still permit an open universe of low mass density and no cosmological constant. Here we derive an independent constraint on the lower bound to the mass density, based on deviations of galaxy velocities from a smooth universal expansion. This constraint rules out a low-density open universe with a vanishing cosmological constant, and together the two favour a nearly flat universe in which the contributions from mass density and the cosmological constant are comparable. This type of universe, however, seems to require a degree of fine tuning of the initial conditions that is in apparent conflict with `common wisdom'.Comment: 8 pages, 1 figure. Slightly revised version. Letter to Natur

Is the Redshift Clustering of Long-Duration Gamma-Ray Bursts Significant?

The 26 long-duration gamma-ray bursts (GRBs) with known redshifts form a distinct cosmological set, selected differently than other cosmological probes such as quasars and galaxies. Since the progenitors are now believed to be connected with active star-formation and since burst emission penetrates dust, one hope is that with a uniformly-selected sample, the large-scale redshift distribution of GRBs can help constrain the star-formation history of the Universe. However, we show that strong observational biases in ground-based redshift discovery hamper a clean determination of the large-scale GRB rate and hence the connection of GRBs to the star formation history. We then focus on the properties of the small-scale (clustering) distribution of GRB redshifts. When corrected for heliocentric motion relative to the local Hubble flow, the observed redshifts appear to show a propensity for clustering: 8 of 26 GRBs occurred within a recession velocity difference of 1000 km/s of another GRB. That is, 4 pairs of GRBs occurred within 30 h_65^-1 Myr in cosmic time, despite being causally separated on the sky. We investigate the significance of this clustering. Comparison of the numbers of close redshift pairs expected from the simulation with that observed shows no significant small-scale clustering excess in the present sample; however, the four close pairs occur only in about twenty percent of the simulated datasets (the precise significance of the clustering is dependent upon the modeled biases). We conclude with some impetuses and suggestions for future precise GRB redshift measurements.Comment: Published in the Astronomical Journal, June 2003: see http://adsabs.harvard.edu/cgi-bin/nph-bib_query?bibcode=2003AJ....125.2865

Cluster versus POTENT Density and Velocity Fields: Cluster Biasing and Omega

The density and velocity fields as extracted from the Abell/ACO clusters are compared to the corresponding fields recovered by the POTENT method from the Mark~III peculiar velocities of galaxies. In order to minimize non-linear effects and to deal with ill-sampled regions we smooth both fields using a Gaussian window with radii ranging between 12 - 20\hmpc. The density and velocity fields within 70\hmpc exhibit similarities, qualitatively consistent with gravitational instability theory and a linear biasing relation between clusters and mass. The random and systematic errors are evaluated with the help of mock catalogs. Quantitative comparisons within a volume containing $\sim\!12$ independent samples yield \betac\equiv\Omega^{0.6}/b_c=0.22\pm0.08, where $b_c$ is the cluster biasing parameter at 15\hmpc. If $b_c \sim 4.5$, as indicated by the cluster correlation function, our result is consistent with $\Omega \sim 1$.Comment: 18 pages, latex, 2 ps figures 6 gif figures. Accepted for pubblications in MNRA

Omega from the skewness of the cosmic velocity divergence

We propose a method for measuring the cosmological density parameter $\Omega$ from the statistics of the divergence field, $\theta \equiv H^{-1} \div v$, the divergence of peculiar velocity, expressed in units of the Hubble constant, $H \equiv 100 h km/s/Mpc$. The velocity field is spatially smoothed over $\sim 10 h^{-1} Mpc$ to remove strongly nonlinear effects. Assuming weakly-nonlinear gravitational evolution from Gaussian initial fluctuations, and using second-order perturbative analysis, we show that \propto -\Omega^{-0.6} ^2. The constant of proportionality depends on the smoothing window. For a top-hat of radius R and volume-weighted smoothing, this constant is $26/7-\gamma$, where $\gamma=-d\log / d\log R$. If the power spectrum is a power law, $P(k)\propto k^n$, then $\gamma=3+n$. A Gaussian window yields similar results. The resulting method for measuring $\Omega$ is independent of any assumed biasing relation between galaxies and mass. The method has been successfully tested with numerical simulations. A preliminary application to real data, provided by the POTENT recovery procedure from observed velocities favors $\Omega \sim 1$. However, because of an uncertain sampling error, this result should be treated as an assessment of the feasibility of our method rather than a definitive measurement of $\Omega$.Comment: 16 pages + 2 figures, uuencoded postscript file, also available by anonymous ftp from ftp.cita.utoronto.ca in directory /cita/francis/div_skewness, CITA 94-1

Lost and found dark matter in elliptical galaxies

The kinematical properties of elliptical galaxies formed during the mergers of equal mass, stars+gas+dark matter spiral galaxies are compared to the observed low velocity dispersions found for planetary nebulae on the outskirts of ellipticals, which have been interpreted as pointing to a lack of dark matter in ellipticals (which poses a problem for the standard model of galaxy formation). We find that the velocity dispersion profiles of the stars in the simulated ellipticals match well the observed ones. The low outer stellar velocity dispersions are mainly caused by the radial orbits of the outermost stars, which, for a given binding energy must have low angular momentum to reach their large radial distances, usually driven out along tidal tails.Comment: Talk presented at 21st IAP meeting, Mass Profiles andShapes of Cosmological Structures. Ed. G. A. Mamon, F. Combes, C. Deffayet & B. Fort (Paris: EDP), 4 pages, 3 figures (4 plots